REVIEWS COURTESY OF ZXSR

Sinclair and the 'Sunrise' Technology
by Ian Adamson, Richard Kennedy
Penguin Books Ltd
1986
Your Computer Issue 1, Jan 1987   page(s) 58

Authors: Ian Adamson and Richard Kennedy
Publisher: Penguin
Price: £3.95

"Why does Sir Clive Sinclair merit our undivided attention?" Surely that is a poor start to a book which will then spend almost 300 pages talking about the countless rises and falls of this idiosyncratic English boffin. Everyone has heard, and lamented, the fall of Sinclair computers to the hands of Amstrad, for the pathetically small fee of £5 million, but this book takes the whole story a great deal further.

Starting with his early pursuits as a technical journalist, and later as an author of such titles as Transistor Subminiature Receivers Handbook for the Home Constructor, the book travels through the life and times of a man who has been described as "Margaret Thatcher's favourite entrepreneur".

One thing which becomes increasingly clear as you proceed further into the book is that by no means was Sir Clive the possessor of a Midas touch. In fact, a great deal of both his early and later ventures were doomed to failure in concept as well as execution.

If there is one criticism that should be made of the book, it is that the first half seems to be spent criticising Sinclair Research, as the product of Margaret Thatcher's economic policy and the second half is a direct attack on Sir Clive. Neither section is justified - they seem to lack cohesion. Apart from that the book is compulsive reading and should be helpful for anyone wondering whether to invest in any new Sinclair ventures.


Transcript by Chris Bourne

ZX Computing Issue 33, Jan 1987   page(s) 31

Penguin Books Ltd
£3.95

The authors, Ian Adamson and Richard Kennedy, have varied and colourful backgrounds including a few credits in the field of computer journalism, though noticeably not in the Sinclair field until now, at least according to their given personal briefs.

This very 'distance' from the whole subject probably stood them in good stead in the writing of the book and contributes to its lack of emotional colouring in favour of the charismatic Sir C.

Unlike some tomes which I have read, the authors do not view Sir Clive Sinclair through rose tinted glasses but by using facts, reports and documented statements they have researched and produced what must be the definitive account of his business ventures to date.

Devotees will find that their concept and perceptions of the man may well need a little reappraising, but even so he has been treated gently and emerges as a likable personality.

You may have gathered by now that this is not a superficial sop to the masses, it does not simply present a potted history of the events and pad it out with opinion, technical references, photographs and diagrams, indeed there are none of the latter and the technical input is limited to brief and easily understood explanations where necessary.

Opinions are part and parcel of the text although they are presented in academically acceptable form as reasonably argued ideas which are well supported by documented evidence and the events of the time. Without taking months to check and correlate on the material presented by them I can only concede that they have a persuasive and almost certainly accurate account of the whole affair.

I am not sure of the market to which this book is aimed, as an authorative academic book it is valuable for schools and colleges for social studies, business and perhaps political courses. The rather dry, unsensational approach would tend to limit its appeal to the more thoughtful individual and in this category I would also put the established hobbyist for 'obsessive' (as the book occasionally labels us), and perhaps the anti-Sinclair brigade who seem to look for any excuse to put him down.

The great majority of Sinclair users will probably not be interested in this book though I found it a fascinating and plausible account of a period of history which may be regarded in our future as the turning point of a new era. Only time will tell.


REVIEW BY: Ray Elder

Transcript by Chris Bourne

All information in this page is provided by ZXSR instead of ZXDB